Ming's tswvyim hais ua dabneeg

Kuv hlub Ming Tsai thiab nws ua faj tim teb chaws li npaum li tus tom ntej 3-am TV tuav. Ua tau, nws cov zaub mov txawv no zoo heev thiab koj yuav tsum tau ua rau koj tus kheej. Tab sis, kuv pom muaj ib tug nyiam khib rau nws hais (paraphrased) “koj yuav tsum nco ntsoov siv cov organic, Nws yog zoo npaum li cas rau koj”. Qhov yoojyim kuv lub puzzled. Txhais li cas xyov yog nws? Ming yog zoo educated thiab qhov no yuav tsis txhua yam uas nws yuav tsum tau lees paub nyuaj rau, tab sis nws echoes yog ib tug misconception tag dhau heev uas muaj organic ua tau zoo. Los zoo dua kuv tabtom txhais no ua tsis muaj mob, uas nkawd ua ib zajlus kom kis tau tus choj. Li ntawd, wb saib cov ntaub ntawv.

Tsis ntev los no thiab muab rov luam tawm hauv qhov Miskas Journal ntawm tej khoom noj haus muaj lom zem ntau convinced kuv txog dab tsi kuv muaj ib skeptical ntawm; tias organic cov khoom noj uas yuav ua tau yuav tsis loo rau koj. Rau lawv lawm lawv muab 55 kev tshawb fawb thiab tuaj rau lub xaus uas “yog tsis muaj pov thawj kev sib txawv hauv as zoo ntawm organically thiab cov conventionally uas ua cov khoom noj”.

Ces yog li cas tus mob? Kuv cov teebmeem nrog rau tag nrho cov no yog tias nws raws li tus naturalistic fallacy, uas “ntuj” los sis “organic” cas txhais tau hais tias qhov khoom ntawd ntseg los yog tsis muaj mob. Pes tsawg zaus vim li koj tau pom lub sij hawm “ntuj” nyob rau hauv lub khw thiab yeej tsis muab nws ob xav? Yog hais tias muaj tej yam uas yeej muaj nyob xeeb dua qub ces nws yog tshuaj Hmoob Ayurvedic cov tshuaj yuav tsis yog lom horribly. Afterall, arsenic, hmoov txhuas thiab cov mercury yog NATURAL – tiam sis lawv kuj yog ib co kev zoo tshaj plaws tebchaw paub tias tus txiv neej. Thaum kawg nws yog 100% li cas.

Los ntawm lwm lub Ming Tsai kuj tsis yog tas li lawm afterall. Kuv tsis muaj tag nrho cov ntaub ntawv pem lub taub hau kuv txog yam paug ntawm cov khoom noj, tiam sis nws tseem zajlus kom kom muaj kev pov plob tsawg lo zoo. Obviously tua kab yuav yog ib tug phem tshaj plaws, muaj cov roob hauv cov ntawv nyeem los pab txhawb nws puas yuav ua rau. Tab sis, tus txiav txim rau nkawd ua raws nraim li cas tsis zoo rau, yog kiag li, tej feeb residues ntawm peb cov zaub mov no. Muaj tej khoom noj los conventionally nqi ntau ntau ntawm residues, tiam sis tej organics tsis pub dawb yam kab mob sib kis. Li ntawd, kuv ntsia nws txawv. Peb cov nyiaj pab ib puag ncig los thaum cov zaub mov kev ruaj ntseg dua. Cov tshuaj tsawg dua cov dumped rau peb waterways, tswv teb yuav tsum battle tsawg haib incredibly co toxins, thiab blinky cov ntses fights saib lwm hnub. Peb yuav tsum tau tag nrho cov siv zog nyob sustainably thiab organic ua teb qhia rau peb tej kev ntug.

Yog li ib zaug rov, tus mob no li cas? Cov neeg uas yuav cov organic tejzaum nws kuj ua li ntawd, based rau txoj environmental zeem. Kuv puas tseem sib ceg tias heev feem pua ntawm cov neeg no tseem ntseeg hais tias cov khoom noj uas tsis muaj mob (leej twg muaj kev ntsuam xyuas cov ntaub ntawv kom them nyiaj yug no thov?). Thiaj li nyob rau hauv no lom cov no ib tug nqa tus. Tab sis npog, rau txoj kev tsis ncaj ncees lawm vim li cas yuav tsum tsis txhob tau xam. Qhov no ntaus hauv lub ncov txog ib qho teeb meem loj uas uas tus neeg tsav yog li thiab pes tsawg science. Case in point – Vitamin C raws txias. Kev tshawb hauv PLOS tshuaj tau pom tias tseem tsis tau txog cov miv nyuas siv zug ntawm VitC tiv thaiv tus mob khaub thuas. Mus rau daim duab, muaj ib zaug believed yuav tsis muaj tseeb tiag staple twb pib mus khaws sib nrug heev los ntawm science thiab cov ntaub ntawv. Wb yuav xyuam xim rau dab bandwagon peb dhia thiab yog vim li cas.